24th January 2025
The AI and Copyright Debate: Why Creators Need an Opt-In Approach
I recently took action that many of us in the creative industries should be paying attention to: I wrote to my MP about the urgent need for an opt-in approach rather than the current opt-out system when it comes to AI training on copyrighted music. The response I received from my MP made one thing crystal clear: this debate is far from over, and we need to keep pushing for a fairer system.
Here are the key takeaways from the government’s stance on the matter:
🎵 AI and the Creative Industries
AI is no longer a far-off concept. It’s already an integral part of our industry, with over 38% of creative businesses already using AI in some form. This is a massive shift, and while AI holds incredible potential, it also poses significant challenges when it comes to protecting creators' rights.
⚖️ Inadequate Protection for Creators
One of the major issues highlighted in the response is that current copyright laws are simply not equipped to deal with the complexities of AI. Creators are often left in a vulnerable position, unable to control or monetise their work when it’s used in AI training. This is a major problem for everyone from musicians to visual artists – and it’s one that we can’t ignore.
❌ The Burden is on Rights Holders
Perhaps the most concerning aspect of the government’s proposal is that it continues to place the burden on rights holders to protect their work. In an era where AI is growing at a pace that’s hard to keep up with, asking creators to chase down how their work is being used is not only unrealistic, but unfair. The solution should be that AI developers seek permission to use copyrighted works in training, not the other way around.
📢 The Need for Ongoing Advocacy
While the issue is being raised in Parliament, it’s clear that we need to continue pushing for a system that balances the interests of creators with the needs of AI developers. Technology companies shouldn’t be at an unfair advantage in this debate, and creators shouldn’t be left fighting to protect their own work.
The government’s consultation on AI and copyright is running until 25 February 2025. If you work in the music, media, or creative industries, now is the time to have your say. This is a crucial moment to shape how AI will interact with our industries – and to ensure that creators are valued, protected, and paid fairly.
As the creative industries continue to evolve, it’s vital we stay ahead of the curve. Let’s ensure the UK remains a place where creativity and innovation are not only embraced but fairly compensated.
Have your say here: Government Consultation on AI and Copyright
Let’s make our voices heard.